I wonder how many things about a city we accept without thought, just because they were already there when we arrived. A narrow sidewalk, a locked gate, the long way around a building because somebody decided there shouldn't be a door on that side. Eventually we just ignore it. We learn the route, we step over the broken pavement, and before too long we're calling the place home.
Which is a rather strange thing, when you consider how little say most of us have in the places we grow attached to.
I mean, we build with practical intentions, of course. Bricks keep out the weather, drains carry away water, roads bring people to work. But there is a social life to these things too. A city can make it easy for people to find one another, or exhaust them just trying. It can ask a neighborhood to share a burden, or quietly arrange for someone else to bear it. I find this to be far more revealing than the height of its monuments.
Mohenjo-Daro, the lost city, in the ancient Indus Valley, comes to mind after recently taking a class on archeology. More than four thousand years ago, people there were building brick-lined wells, bathing spaces, and an elaborate system for carrying wastewater away from their homes. Even the Great Bath survives among the ruins, though its purpose is still debated. There is no unmistakable royal palace of the sort we find in some other ancient cities, either. That alone tells us very little about who held power, and it would be careless to imagine a society without inequality simply because we haven't found a king's living quarters. Still though, the drains interest me. More than the grand buildings, really. Someone had to craft them, keep them in good condition, and determine their final destination. The people of Mohenjo-Daro probably cursed a blocked channel just as readily as we complain about a flooded street. They had no reason to think strangers would be admiring their sanitation thousands of years later. They were trying to live there.
Our own cities have left other kinds of evidence.
In Detroit, in 1941, a developer erected a six-foot concrete wall between an established Black neighborhood and a proposed white subdivision. Federal housing officials had refused to insure the new development's mortgages without separation from the neighboring community. A wall, apparently, made the difference. It is known as the Birwood Wall, and parts of it still stand.
There is a photograph from August of that year, taken by John Vachon, of children beside the wall. I can only make guesses about what an object meant to most people, but these were children, with their own things to worry about, their own little worlds, and I'd rather not put speeches in their mouths. The adults responsible for the concrete, however, were clear enough in their intentions. And what a peculiar sort of architecture it is. It made no one warmer. It brought no water into a home. Its purpose was to say that one set of neighbors ought to remain apart from another.
Today portions of the wall carry murals. I like that its meaning has been challenged without the history being hidden. The thing itself is still there. So is the question of what we inherit when we inherit a place. We inherit the less visible decisions as well. Research into formerly redlined American neighborhoods has revealed higher exposure to heat and flooding decades after the maps were drawn, partly due to differences in tree cover and the ground beneath the streets. Think of a child growing up with hardly any shade on the way home. They might never know the names of the officials who helped make their neighborhood that way. They would know the heat.
I have been returning to this while working on Fernaea, where the environment gives people little room to be careless about shelter. The planet's eccentric orbit brings a lush, extravagant summer followed by Ondra: forty-eight days of sudden, murderous cold. You can build a beautiful city there. You had better also build one that survives winter.
Narimour is the oldest recognized human settlement on Fernaea, founded by King Arda in a sheltered coastal valley. Its early scholars marked the first 288-day calendars in clay, trying to predict the frost-lock. Centuries later, the old canals have become tidal aqueducts and the city has grown into a crowded spread of white limestone and green solar-glass. I love the image of that ancient valley still visible beneath so much new construction. Technology has changed. The land, of course, has not. One feature of Narimour has always interested me. Its wealthiest families did not settle above everyone else. They built at the lowest, most protected part of the valley. The roads and waterways draw people inward, toward a center that even the powerful cannot entirely separate themselves from. Living there has practical advantages; I don't think the original inhabitants thought about how charming their future town plan would look to an anthropologist. They needed somewhere to endure the winter month, Ondra.
I think about what that history does to a person. If every year your family prepares for the same dangerous cold, if the shelter that protected your grandparents is the shelter you are preparing to enter, does the city begin to feel like something larger than its buildings? A sort of agreement, renewed whenever the temperature falls. Perhaps. Wealth doesn't vanish just because people share an aqueduct, and a stranger arriving at the valley may find little of the comfort its oldest families take for granted. But the arrangement makes a certain promise. No one can pretend that winter belongs only to the poor.
Arbordon makes no such promise.
Seven hundred thousand people live along its great southern slope, from the wet delta bay to the cliffs overlooking the northern sea. Down by the water, the Crimson Slums are built from red coral blocks and the wreckage of old ships. There is salt in everything. The ground collects coral-stained puddles; commercial jets leave a sharp, metallic smell in the air; and the stairs rise so relentlessly through the buildings that daylight is something you stumble upon.
It sounds miserable when I describe it that way, and for many people it is. But I don't want to write the inhabitants out of their own city. Arguments would occur behind the thin walls, meals would be prepared, children would know which staircase is faster and which one gets flooded. There would be a particular corner that someone misses after moving away. Perhaps the worst thing about Arbordon is that those below have made homes in a place that treats them as expendable. And, climb far enough and the air changes. High Arbordon, home of the Noct family and the High Directorate, rises in pale diorite and marble. Its glass bridges extend over the cliff; the sea opens beneath them. From there the lower city is distant, almost decorative, a wash of roofs and haze that the residents need never enter. In Narimour, the valley draws people together. Here the slope has been made into a measure of worth. The wealthy have purchased distance, and with it the luxury of forgetting what happens below.
There is something worse than the distance, though. West of Arbordon, broken coastal bluffs conceal the Solace of Stillands, a secular academy carved into white stone. Between its walls and a freestanding training plateau lies the Basin, a gorge so deep and fogged that sunlight scarcely reaches the floor. Hidden in its black foundation rock is the Cattle Matrix. Failed students, unregistered Lythes, and people taken during arrests in the slums are kept behind iron grates and used to power the city.
In this universe, the soul is a real fragment of the Mother Star Ignaea's core. Copper resonance wires siphon energy from those fragments while the prisoners are kept in a state of deliberate distress. The power travels upward. The palaces shine. Most people in Arbordon do not know this. When the local authorities sweep through the lower classes, citizens in middle-class neighborhoods might even cheer. They think the streets are being made safer. The machinery beneath the cliffs is conveniently out of sight, and there are dinners to prepare and children to put to bed. Life goes on, as it tends to do.
I sometimes wonder how much suffering a person can live beside without knowing it is there. The comparison with our own world shouldn't be taken too literally; no city is harvesting souls. But we have built plenty of comforts on labor and histories we would rather not examine closely. A beautiful facade is useful for more than hiding ugly machinery.
Arbordon is home to the people it harms. That, to me, is the part that stays. Its residents will remember childhoods in the Crimson Slums, the voices of neighbors, the view from a familiar stairway. None of those memories becomes worthless because the Directorate has decided the people holding them are.
Perhaps one day they'll tear down the cliffs. I can understand the temptation.
But the morning after, someone will still have to work out how to get clean water into the lower streets, where to put the stairs once another set has been destroyed, which homes need repairing first. There will be arguments. Somebody will undoubtedly complain about the drains of course.
But, I'd like to think they'll listen to voices big and small.